20210312, 22:01  #1 
Mar 2017
3×5 Posts 
Best distributed computing project for CPUs?
Not sure where (which forum) this should go...
I've been running GIMPS since 1996 when a person had to manually contact George to get work assignments. However, I feel as if my CPUs are no longer well suited to searching for Mersenne primes, that GPUs are the place to be these days. I really have no interest in going down the GPU road. Are there still distributed computing projects for which CPUs have an advantage or, like the dinosaurs, is my CPUdominated contribution to the world of distributed computing a relic of the past? My Googlefoo is not strong on this subject for some reason so I figured the smart folks on these fora would point me in the right direction. Thanks, Lumpy 
20210312, 22:09  #2 
"Curtis"
Feb 2005
Riverside, CA
5071_{10} Posts 
This reads a bit like an invitation for us to shill our pet projects, so I'll do so:
numberfieldsieve (NFS) factoring is an interesting place to be, and most of the tasks involved are CPUonly (or at least commonly done on CPU, in the case of ECM). Your contribution can be: 1. Fireandforget via BOINC client pointed at nfs@home (I suggest the fsmall selection in particular if helping we forum denizens makes you happy, or leave default to help all the subprojects within that factoring effort) 2. Independent work on an aliquot sequence, where each term is the sum of the previous term's factors. This is best if you have interest in learning how the individual factoring tools work. YAFU is the software wrapper that handles most of the work. 3. You can run ECM work, either on a number of the size that might get factored by NFS in the future, or on mersenne exponents. See the "getting under 20M unfactored" thread for details on that Mersenne subproject's work. If factoring isn't your thing, running LLR or PFGW on smaller exponents to search for primes is still done on CPU alone (LLR has a GPU version, but it's not a great use of GPU resources and CPU version is more efficient). Conjectures R Us and the riesel prime search subforums are popular examples of teams organizing work, but the prime search is mostly independent and at your own pace. 
20210312, 22:45  #3 
6809 > 6502
"""""""""""""""""""
Aug 2003
101Γ103 Posts
2·5,059 Posts 
There is still a huge back log of LLDC's that need to get done. (These can also be done as a PRP with a cert.) CPU's are still worthwhile in this range. And even though GPU's may be vastly more powerful, all cycles contribute.
Also, there is the newish task of doing a PRP test on the cofactors of Mersenne numbers. This allows us to know if the cofactor is prime (and thus the Mersenne number is fully factored) or not. Right now those are being done in the 10.8M range and up. So, an older CPU can turn these in frequently. It is not as glamorous as finding a new prime, but an old CPU can continue to contribute. 
20210313, 07:44  #4 
"Carlos Pinho"
Oct 2011
Milton Keynes, UK
3×1,663 Posts 
Iβm on 1) and sometimes I help GIMPS on P1 but Iβm on the same boat as you are. My laptop is too slow for first wave. Happy to support you on 1) at NFS@Home.

20210313, 14:42  #5 
Mar 2017
3×5 Posts 
Thanks for the responses, folks. For now, I've switched my CPUs to working on the DC backlog while I investigate nfs@home. I did fiddle with the BOINC client 10 years ago or so during a brief SETI@home phase, but always kept my toes in the GIMPS waters.
Thanks! Lumpy 
20210329, 08:20  #6 
May 2005
England, UK
2^{2}×31 Posts 
I've got an old laptop that is very slow by modern standards (Intel Pentium M Mobile @ 2.26 GHz), and it has 2 GB of RAM.
Which of these ECM subprojects have the shortest assignments? 5  ECM for first factors of Mersenne numbers 8  ECM on Mersenne cofactors 
20210329, 14:05  #7  
Bamboozled!
"πΊππ·π·π"
May 2003
Down not across
11026_{10} Posts 
Quote:
Integer factorization, for instance. My ECMNET server is plugging away after many years. There are some Number Field Sieve collaborations too. If you would like to help me out, the minimum you need to know is one line in a configuration file. server=100:a:83.217.167.177:8194 I can provide vastly more information to get you up and running relatively easily. Paul 

20210329, 14:59  #8  
Mar 2017
3·5 Posts 
Quote:
Thanks for the response. I'm presently pumping out 34 LL double checks per day (a drop in the bucket as to what is needed?) but would be interested in hearing more about ECMNET. Not sure I'll switch over (one big thing that GIMPS provides is a "set it and forget it" client), but I would like to hear more. Best, Lumpy 

20210329, 16:23  #9 
P90 years forever!
Aug 2002
Yeehaw, FL
1E03_{16} Posts 
I suspect 8 would be faster and more likely to have occasional successes. 5 is a little more noteworthy when you have a success. Your machine is well suited to either work preference.

20210329, 17:41  #10  
May 2005
England, UK
124_{10} Posts 
Quote:
It's just a shame that you can't specify 'certification' as a work type, although I suspect that there might not be enough certification work for everyone who would like to do it. It's a pity, because it would give slow computers a real chance to take part in this project in a meaningful way. 

20210426, 06:35  #11 
Aug 2020
79*6581e4;3*2539e3
2×211 Posts 
Interesting that you perceive it that way, I always thought CPUs are suprior to GPU when it comes to prime hunting and only specialized applications such as TF or primality of generalized Fermat numbers is for GPU. Deterministic prime tests for most types of primes such as with LLR and pfgw are most efficient on CPU to my knowledge.
If you want a fireandforget for prime hunting outside GIMPS I think your best bet is Primegrid. It's a BOINC project that does primality tests on a large variety of prime numbers. You can choose what you want to test and then just leave it running. It's very userfriendly due to it using the BOINC framework. And with the many subprojects, if you get bored by one search you can switch to another. So LL tests on Mersenne numbers are more efficient on GPU than on CPU? 
Thread Tools  
Similar Threads  
Thread  Thread Starter  Forum  Replies  Last Post 
AlphaZero style distributed computing project for Go and Chess  MooMoo2  Lounge  5  20190528 13:22 
distributed computing project to prove/disprove Riemann Hypothesis  ssybesma  Other Mathematical Topics  10  20181218 13:26 
GNFS distributed computing  andi314  Factoring  50  20050511 00:56 
A distributedcomputing project to optimize GIMPS FFT? Genetic algorithms  GP2  Software  10  20031209 20:41 
The difference between P2P and distributed computing and grid computing  GP2  Lounge  2  20031203 14:13 